Top 10 Most Valuable Hockey Cards - HobbyLark - Games and Hobbies
Updated date:

Top 10 Most Valuable Hockey Cards

Hockey Card History

Hockey cards have been around for over a hundred years. From the earliest tobacco cards through the classic 1950s issues to cards of today's superstars like Sidney Crobsy or Alexander Ovechkin, the cardboard depiction of the stars of the National Hockey League continue to delight fans of all ages.

Who can stake the claim as most expensive? Howe? Hull? Orr? Gretzky? This is a tight-knit field with room for several cards to move up the list in the coming years. For now, these are the top 10 most valuable hockey cards:

10. Bobby Orr: 1966 Topps USA Test PSA 7 ($10,600)

Arguably the greatest player of all time, Bobby Orr is a true hockey legend. The 1966 Topps USA Test set was a very limited issue similar to the regular issue, but with back in English only as opposed to the bilingual information found on the standard issues. It is rare to find in any condition and this excellent example of the Bruins legend commanded a very strong price.

Jacques Plante

Jacques Plante

9. Jacques Plante: 1955 Quaker Oats SGC 84 ($12,000)

The great goalie Jake the Snake makes a splash onto the list with his 1955 Quaker Oats card. Made by Parkhurst and distributed in Quaker Oats, the cards boast a similar design to the regular Parkhurst issue, but have different color ink on back. This card boasts a great action shot of Plante without the famous mask he was responsible for launching into everyday use. Condition is an issue as these cards were distributed inside containers of Quaker Oats and were easily damaged in transport.

Guy LaFleur

Guy LaFleur

8. Guy LaFleur: 1971 O-Pee-Chee PSA 10 ($12,300)

Fresh off his monumental 130 goal season in the Quebec Junior League, LaFleur made his rookie card debut on the great 1971 OPC set. An absolute perfect grade rookie fetched more than $12,000 to a serious collector. The Blonde Devil had about as many misadventures off the ice as great plays on the ice, but remains a fan favorite. The Hall of Fame came calling for Guy in 1988.

Bobby Hull

Bobby Hull

7. Bobby Hull: 1958 Topps PSA 8 ($13,000)

The Golden Jet makes his NHL debut appearance as a Chicago Black hawks rookie on this 1958 Topps hockey card. Another Hall of Fame great and another legitimate contender for greatest hockey player of all time and definitely the greatest left winger the game has ever known.

Georges Vezina

Georges Vezina

6. Georges Vezina: 1911 Imperial Tobacco PSA 7 ($13,200)

Pioneering goalie, Vezina has the honor of being on the oldest card to make the list among the word's most expensive hockey cards. The future Hall of Famer is depicted as a young star on this Canadian issue tobacco card.

Gordie Howe

Gordie Howe

5. Gordie Howe: 1954 Topps SGC 96 ($13,200)

The second card on the list from the 1954 Topps issue and the second appearance on the list for the legend Howe. Although his rookie card was from years earlier on the Parkhurst set, this mainstream issue has more appeal and the condition for this particular sale is incredibly close to perfection.

Mario Lemieux

Mario Lemieux

4. Mario Lemieux: 1985 O-Pee-Chee BVG 10 ($14,500)

Mario Lemieux accomplished as much as anyone in the history of the game during his long and illustrious career. A scoring machine, the powerful Lemieux could and did score in every imaginable way: shorthanded, penalty, empty net. The Hall of Fame was all too eager to enshrine Lemieux once he was retired only to find Mario back on the ice. He joined Howe and Lafleur as the only three players to take the ice again after being enshrined.

Gordie Howe

Gordie Howe

3. Gordie Howe: 1951 Parkhurst PSA 9 ($17,980)

The rookie card of Gordie Howe would be sought after from any set, but the Parkhurst issue is especially tough. Smaller than today's cards, the Parkhurst hockey set was issued on thin paper stock and once cut is said to have been mixed up inside a cement mixer for generating randomness for collation. Needless to say, few mint examples survived. Any high grade Parkhurst cards are valuable, but this one of the ageless Mr. Hockey is particularly valuable.

Bobby Orr

Bobby Orr

2. Bobby Orr: 1966 Topps PSA 9 ($47,600)

Just as Orr makes a solid case for greatest hockey player of all time, so does his 1966 Topps card make a play for most valuable. Remaining well within striking distance of the #1 spot, this high grade example keep the quest for Most Valuable Hockey card a two man race. Both the 1966 Test Issue and Regular Issue make the top 10 list, but with a substantial price difference.

Wayne Gretzky

Wayne Gretzky

1. Wayne Gretzky: 1979 O-Pee-Chee BVG 9.5 ($50,000)

The Great One. Regarded by many as simply the greatest hockey player of all time, there are not enough superlatives to describe the legend. Wayne's 1979 OPC debut features a youthful Gretzky with the Edmonton Oilers. The man who once had a shared interest in the Most Valuable Baseball Card of all time, makes his own statement with the most sought after hockey card.

Card Value in Hockey vs. Other Sports

Hockey cards are experiencing a growth in the number of collectors, but prices fall well shy of baseball greats. These depictions of the ice legends do compare favorably to the all-time Most Valuable Football Cards and the Most Valuable Basketball Cards, though.

Comments

bettie on July 19, 2020:

i have Wayne Gretzky Mario Lemieux, and I am quite sure I have Guy La Fleur Ifound these along with thousands of baseball cards and hundred or so football and as I mentioned about fifty hockey cards in an estate I just inherited

Frankie Big Pants on March 07, 2019:

I had that Lemieux card there. Check out this story. Friend of a friend came over to trade (middle school days). He traded me that card for nhl hockey pucks with team logos on them that they sold at the games. I had a few dozen of different teams. The police show up at my door a few weeks later. They asked me if I had that card. I told him I did. Gave it to him. He said it was stolen. Ended up that the guy that traded me; his friend stole it. I knew "of" the person it was stolen from. Suffice to say, I was out my pucks and the card. That ended my trading except for close friends. The guy got his card back so good for him.

Darlene Gale on January 29, 2018:

Found a binder of hockey cards that my son put together in the 80s wondering are they have any value

christina on January 10, 2018:

i have a complete sheet of old baseball players from opeechee.. do you think it is worth anything

Samuel Franklin on October 25, 2014:

Wow I can't believe the costs of some of these!

wiserworld on July 17, 2013:

True, the card quality grade is important. Frayed corners will significantly reduce the value of the card. Nice article.

sound_foundation (author) on May 04, 2012:

@bosterdamus - actually it is now low on the Gretzky. A PSA 10 just sold May 1st for over $90,000 and I will be updating this article. Buyers may offer $1000 for an ungraded example, but tell me where I can get a 9.5 or above for $1000? The grade is everything! Of the over 1500 cards submitted to Beckett, I think only 2 Gretzkys have graded over 9.5. This is what makes it so high. Run-of-the-mill Gretzky rookies are everywhere.

Bobsterdamus from Calgary on April 30, 2012:

I have two Wayne's and I am broke. Not accurate. Most buyers offer $1000 or so.

sound_foundation (author) on December 29, 2011:

@pat - I am unaware of any 1903 card for Riley Hern. He has two Imperial Tobacco cards from 1910 and 1911. Both can generally be had in Good condition for around $100 or a bit more each. Prices escalate rapidly based on condition - especially graded.

sound_foundation (author) on September 21, 2011:

@CalgaryFlamesfan - these prices are based on a REAL sale and not speculation. Will the same card in the same grade still bring the same money? Who knows, but at least one buyer and seller exchanged these cards at these prices.

JRBanks on September 20, 2011:

It is amazing how much the value is effected after you grade it. The trick is to know what other cards will become valuable! I bough a lot of martin brodeur rookie cards :D

daskittlez69 from midwest on July 28, 2011:

It is time to pull out the old hockey cards from the attic and take a look. Thanks for the hub!

CalgaryFlamesfan!!!! on July 26, 2011:

Nice Cards. I have a lot of old cards, so I will go through them. And I have a question, are these cards valued in your opinion or how much they actually go for?

Thanks, and go Flames and Jets!!

FlyersFan on July 08, 2011:

@mickel Clearly your friend has no knowledge of hockey at all lol one of the greatest players to lace up and just gives the card away? Ask him if he has anything else he wants to give you lol

mickel on July 01, 2011:

wow my friend gave me the # 8 for free he thought it was a crappy card

sound_foundation (author) on April 27, 2011:

@hockey card guy - you make some good points about regional sales being higher. The Gretzky @ $50K obviously sold several years. The only reason that GMA probably didn't go higher is that it is NOT one of the the big three grading companies.

Hockey Card Guy on April 25, 2011:

There is a guy would sold the Lemieux Rookie graded Becketts 10 on ebay for $5000, the guy who bought it is trying to flip it for $8500,,,,he has had it up for a few months now,,,I don't believe Becketts Book Values, there is no way they can determine the value of sets or cards, my buddy says they over inflate prices so when a new card collector starts collecting they think they're cards are worth a mint so they buy more, then try and sell them and get nowhere near the book value,,,if you sell on ebay you have to sell something unique and still you wont get the price your beckets says unless you have been selling on there for years and have a customer base already, or if you live in Montreal, Montrealers get high prices for they're cards, but I think they buy cards of each other at huge prices that no one else is getting so they can become ebay powersellers faster and save 20% for being a top rated powerseller,,,I sell on ebay, I have one of a kind cards up and still no one is really buying, lots of window shopping but not really to many sales,,,average cards forget it,,,,numbered cards /10 you can make a bit of cash, but you have to wait till that collector comes around and really want the card, maybe once or twice a month,,,I don't know who's paying the prices this website is saying but it sure is not on ebay and that is the place to get all of the cards above,,,,and in the last 3 years I have not seen a single Gretzky rookie 9.5 go for $50,000 grand, one went last week at 9.5 for $14,500 but I think that is because there was a letter from the owners of GMA who said it was the first and only GMA Gretzky rookie graded 9.5 with specific details on how they graded the card and why,,,,,a bobby orr topps rookie graded 9.5 did sell for $87,000 but they figure there may only be less then 100 of those cards and that took him over a year to sell it and you wont find to many of those around graded like that so you wait for a millionare to come around and if he wants an $87,000 conversation piece he'll buy it but you'll be waiting a long time for that guy to come around

sound_foundation (author) on March 22, 2011:

@ Scott - You can join PSA and get it graded, but if this can be expensive. Many card shops offer PSA grading services where you can drop your card off and they submit it for you. Also, if you live near a large city, PSA often sets up at major card shows and does on-the-spot grading.

HI IM SCOTT! on March 20, 2011:

I Have the Bobby Orr - 1966 Topps how do i go about getting ti PSA tested cause mine is in a case and has never been taken out...in fact it might already be PSA tested it has a little slip of paper with it inside the case it is in mint condition but how would i go about getting someone to buy it

sound_foundation (author) on February 04, 2011:

@BobBigWheel - there are many great online price guides, but most focus on graded cards only because that is really the current state of the hobby. Vintagecardprices.com is a great choice, but you pay by the month. I think Beckett also has an online price guide. Many companies still publish annual guides and there are still monthly magazines too. Thanks for reading!

BobBigWheel from Toronto, ON, Canada on February 02, 2011:

Great Hub! I really enjoyed collecting hockey cards when I was younger, and I still have a decent collection. I actually kept all my old price guides too. Do they still make those? Is there an online version?

sound_foundation (author) on January 18, 2011:

@RA Brown - If you can get it graded and it comes back GEM MINT 10 like the example, I assure you it will be very easy to find someone willing to pay $14,500 for it. It would probably even bring more. Condition is everything.

R.A. Brown on January 14, 2011:

I have the Mario Lemieux rookie card but I'm wondering where to find the person who will pay $14,500 for it?!

sound_foundation (author) on September 08, 2010:

@ jack. I agree with you that these prices are fairly silly. You can buy a nice example for much less. It is like this with anything. Someone in the world has the nicest 62 Thunderbird or whatever and I'm sure it is worth many multiples of a daily driver. People want what they want and are willing (obviously) to pay for it. I'm a much lower grade collector and love my cards just the same.

jack palmerston on September 06, 2010:

An interesting page here, but those prices are for perfect samples which only matter to rich perfectionists and wannabees. The guy who mentioned eBay above is right. All these cards can be had starting at .99c on eBay.

~jack at rainbarrel.ca

sound_foundation (author) on September 02, 2010:

DM - you are correct in that lesser condition cards are not worth this money. These cards were given the assigned grades by PSA/SGC or Beckett and represent some of the rarest cards in the world. These prices are ACTUAL sale prices so technically, yes, the card is worth that. At least to some buyer. Many of these can be bought in lesser conditions for a fraction of the price. There is much competition between collectors for graded cards and sometimes the difference between an 8 and a 9 can be hundreds or thousands of dollars. It is just the nature of the hobby now.

dm on September 02, 2010:

look on ebay, these cards arent worth nearly what the article claims

Local Realtor from Wareham on August 23, 2010:

Hockey cards are very nice. I own a ton of cards all sports but I have noticed the hockey rookies the last five years have been worth quite a lot of money, especially Sid the kid Oveckin, and Malkins. Look at the cards called the Cup over 100 bucks a pack. The Sidney Crosby is like 10,000 dollars. Crazy, nice hub.

Derek D from United States on June 30, 2010:

I would have never of thought hockey cards would be worth that kind of money..........Amazing!!!!!!!!!

Seakay from Florida on June 28, 2010:

Love watching hockey...especially Tampa Bay! My friend's daughter got married in the hockey uniforms! Obviously not a church wedding! LOL

mtsi1098 on April 10, 2010:

great hub...looks like I am in the wrong business...

mtsi1098 on April 10, 2010:

looks like I am in the wrong business...Very good hub and I love hockey