Deborah is a research enthusiast! She takes special interest in the world's ancient mysteries.
Revisiting the world of Harry Potter will reveal the top ten most compelling Harry Potter fan theories. Keep in mind, of course, that these theories are pure speculation and have had no verification from the plot of the Harry Potter series.
1. Harry Imagined Everything
Harry Potter was an abused child and did not have a happy life in the care of the Dursleys. It has been speculated that Harry imagined the whole thing, including Hogwarts and magic. The entire Harry Potter series was out of the imagination of Harry to escape a traumatized childhood. J.K. Rowling has stated that this particular theory is not entirely ridiculous.
2. Ginny Used a Love Potion on Harry
Ginny had a childhood crush on Harry. In Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, Harry started to become attracted to Ginny. It has been noted by some fans that his interest in Ginny seemed a bit spontaneous; after all, Harry had never noticed Ginny before.
It is believed that this is because Ginny slipped him a love potion. Harry and Ginny begin to date in the same timeframe that the girls in Hogwarts, including Gryffindor house, were buying love potions from the Weasley twins' shop and smuggling them into Hogwarts. Romilda Vane attempted to give Harry a love potion via a box of chocolates, which Ron ate instead. There is no other specific incident of a love potion described, but the girls' use of these potions is mentioned. Did Ginny slip Harry a love potion?
3. Harry Is a Horcrux
Why are the Dursleys so horrible? Fans have speculated that it is because Harry himself is a Horcrux. In the Deathly Hallows, Ron is severely affected by a Horcrux. It is pointed out that Horcruxes affect a person’s personality negatively. It is revealed that Harry himself is a Horcrux in the final climax of the Deathly Hallows. Fans have speculated that the Dursleys are so mean because they are living with a piece of Voldemort’s soul.
4. Harry, Snape, and Voldemort Are the Deathly Hallows
In the story of the Deathly Hallows, each of the three brothers met death in a different way. It has been suggested that three of the characters from the Harry Potter plot match the tale of the three brothers. One brother dies because of his greed for power, one from a tragedy of love, and the other greeted death as a friend.
The plot of the three brothers resembles Harry, Snape, and Voldemort’s story. Voldemort did eventually die seeking the elder wand. Snape died out of "love," more in analogy. Harry metaphorically greeted death as a friend.
5. Neville Had the Wrong Wand
During the series, Neville’s magic was sometimes inferior to his classmates. He says about himself that he is “almost a squib.” It was pointed out that Neville was using the wand that he inherited from his father. Fans have noted that the wand could not have been his fit, so his magical abilities would suffer.
Furthermore, when Neville’s wand brakes at the ministry, his powers seem to excel. Neville kills Nagini in the final battle. Fans believe his triumph reveals his strength and magical talent.
6. Harry Potter Is Not the Chosen One
It is a common theory that Harry is not actually the chosen one. This theory is not surprising do to the fact that Dumbledore tells Harry that it could have been Neville who was chosen, but Voldemort sealed Harry’s fate as the chosen one when he chose him to target. This theory suggests that Harry is not the chosen one during the entire series in spite of what Voldemort’s actions were when Harry was an infant. Fans have pointed out that it was Neville Longbottom who kills Nagini.
7. Dumbledore Is Death
Fans have claimed that Dumbledore is death. In the Deathly Hallows, death himself gives the humble brother his own invisibility cloak. Dumbledore gives Harry the invisibility cloak as a gift. J.K. Rowling says this is one of her favorite theories.
8. Severus Snape Is a Vampire
Severus Snape has been believed by fans to be a vampire. This is a popular theory, especially at the beginning of the Harry Potter books. It all started with the quote, “bat-like cape.” He is never described eating things, leading some to believe he is a vampire.
9. Muggles Defeated Wizards
This theory points to the conspiracy of keeping the wizarding world secret. There is speculation that muggles defeated wizards years ago in a war between muggles and wizards, before the timeframe of the Harry Potter books. That is why there is prejudice in the wizarding world towards muggles, and wizards are adamant about keeping the magical world secret.
10. Draco Is a Werewolf
A popular fan theory is that Draco Malfoy is a werewolf. It is believed this theory has been debunked by the final installments of the Harry Potter series. It is still debated among fans whether or not Draco is a werewolf. It is usually his pale complexion and conflicted personality that gives fuel to this theory.
There are many more theories to be tinkered with. For now, these ones have intrigued imaginations with the magical world of Harry Potter.
Questions & Answers
Question: Could you please explain the "Draco Is a Werewolf" theory a bit more? And I love the "Snape Is a Vampire" theory! I will never be able to read Harry Potter the same way again!
Answer: Draco is thought to be a werewolf because of his paleness and nasty behavior. He has actually been compared to Lupin. Fans claim Lupin was at times frail and ill because of his transformations and Draco's palor is a direct result of transformations as well.
Bukola on June 16, 2018:
This theories are very good and reasonable. Now I see Harry P differently.